Credentialing icon
Get free credentialing when you sign up for SimplePractice

The before-you-submit insurance checklist (with a sample CMS 1500 form filled out)

Published November 19, 2026

simple illustration of a SOAP template document

Download the before-you-submit insurance checklist

Download now
Yellow clipboard with checked-off boxes beside a calendar, the steps to follow when reviewing a sample CMS 1500 form filled out
simple illustration of a SOAP template document

Download the before-you-submit insurance checklist

Download now

Key takeaways

  • Start with Box 1a: the Member ID must match the insurance card exactly, as it does in the sample CMS 1500 form filled out.
  • Diagnosis pointers in Box 24E must match a filled-in International Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision (ICD-10) line in Box 21. In Box 24B, use place of service 11 for in-person sessions, 10 for telehealth when the client is at home, and 02 when the client is elsewhere.
  • Group practices need both the rendering NPI in Box 24J and the billing NPI in Box 33a. Solo practitioners billing under their own NPI use the same number in both.
  • Solutions for common claim submission errors include verifying eligibility before the first session, checking whether each payer requires an electronic claim-filing enrollment, and running your clearinghouse’s claim scrubber.

Few things slow down a practice like a claim that comes back before it reaches the payer. Most of these rejections come from small data-entry mistakes on the CMS 1500 form, and they differ from the claim denials in medical billing that a payer issues after reviewing a claim.

For more on getting your setup right, see how to reduce billing errors in your private practice.

Below, you’ll find a sample CMS 1500 form filled out, a clear answer on what goes in Box 33 on CMS 1500, and solutions for common claim submission errors, so you can catch problems before you click submit.

What is the CMS 1500 form?

The CMS 1500 form is the standard claim form used to bill Medicare, Medicaid, and private insurance payers. The form itself groups Boxes 1-13 as patient and insured information and Boxes 14-33 as physician or supplier information, and the National Uniform Claim Committee (NUCC) publishes a reference instruction manual that explains how to complete each box. For pre-submission checks, three ranges matter most:

  • Boxes 1-13: patient and insurance information

  • Boxes 21-24: diagnosis and treatment details

  • Boxes 25-33: provider and billing information

What should I check on a claim before I submit it?

Review these boxes every time to reduce pre-submission errors, then check your claim against the sample CMS 1500 form filled out below:

  • Box 1a (Member ID): Confirm the ID matches the card your client gave you exactly, and verify the policy is active. Also make sure the payer is one you (or your group) are credentialed with, and that the clinician listed is the one credentialed with that payer.

  • Boxes 21 and 24E (diagnosis pointers): The letter in Box 24E must point to a valid mental health ICD-10 code in Box 21. A pointer to an empty line is an easy mistake to make.

  • Box 24B (place of service): Enter 11 for in-person sessions. For telehealth, the code follows where the client is, not where you are. Use 10 when the client is at home and 02 when the client is anywhere else. The CMS place of service code set lists the official definitions. Some payers have their own telehealth rules, such as requiring a modifier or a different code, so confirm with each payer before you submit.

  • Box 24D (procedure code): Confirm the CPT code matches the session length and any modifier your payer requires.

‌

Sample CMS 1500 form filled out

Here is a sample CMS 1500 form filled out with fictional information for an individual therapy session by a solo practitioner billing under their own NPI:

Box

Example entry

What to verify

1a

XYZ123456789

Matches the insurance card exactly

2 / 3

Doe, Jane / 04 12 1988

Name and birth date match the card

4 / 6

Doe, Jane / Self

Subscriber name and relationship to the insured are correct

21 (A)

F41.1

Valid ICD-10 code, indicator set to “0”

24A

10 06 2026

Date of service is correct

24B

11

Place of service fits the session type

24D

90837

CPT code matches the session

24E

A

Points to the diagnosis in Box 21

24J

1234567893

Rendering provider’s NPI (same as 33a here because this is a solo practice)

25

123456789

Tax ID matches what the payer has on file

33 / 33a

Practice name, address, phone / 1234567893

Billing provider info and NPI

This example shows a solo practitioner billing under an individual NPI, so Boxes 24J and 33a match. In a group practice, Box 24J holds the clinician’s individual NPI and Box 33a holds the group’s billing NPI, so the two numbers differ.

All names, IDs, and numbers above are fictional.

If you use SimplePractice, you can create and print CMS 1500 claim forms straight from your account.

What goes in Box 33 on the CMS 1500 form?

Box 33 is the billing provider section: the name, address, and phone number of whoever receives payment. Box 33a holds the billing provider’s NPI, as shown in the sample CMS 1500 form filled out above.

Group practice owners: Box 33 deserves special attention. A common pre-submission error is a missing or unlinked NPI. Make sure both the individual rendering provider’s NPI (Box 24J) and the group’s billing NPI (Box 33a) appear on the claim.

Solo practitioners: Box 33 matters for you too. Whether you use an individual or organizational NPI should match how you’re credentialed with the payer, and your tax ID in Box 25 should line up with it. If you bill under your individual NPI, the same number goes in Boxes 24J and 33a. A mismatch is a common reason for rejection.

What are the most common mistakes that get claims rejected?

Most pre-submission rejections trace back to a short list of mistakes:

  • Member ID typos or mismatches

  • Diagnosis pointers that don’t match Box 21

  • Incorrect place-of-service codes

  • Missing or mismatched NPIs

  • Wrong subscriber or relationship information

  • Billing under a clinician who isn’t credentialed with that payer

Why do my claims keep coming back before they even reach the payer?

If your claims keep getting sent back, don’t panic. Rejections at this stage usually come from your clearinghouse or the payer’s front-end system, and they are fixable. Here are the likely culprits:

Electronic enrollment gaps: Most payers accept electronic claims without a separate claim-filing enrollment, but some do require one. Medicare, for example, requires a signed EDI enrollment form before it accepts electronic claims, whether you submit directly or through a clearinghouse. If a payer requires it and you haven’t completed it, the clearinghouse rejects the claim because it isn’t authorized to route your data to that payer. Enrolling isn’t the same as credentialing, and you generally need to be credentialed with a payer before it approves your enrollment.

Demographic and Member ID mismatches: Look again at Boxes 1-13. A single-character discrepancy can make the system reject the claim because it can’t locate the patient. If you bill for services rendered to dependents, check Boxes 4 and 6 closely. Billing software can default the patient to the primary subscriber, so make sure the relationship status is accurate.

How can claims errors be prevented?

These solutions for common claim submission errors take minutes but save weeks:

  1. Verify eligibility before the first session, and again at the start of each year.

  2. Keep a credentialing cheat sheet listing each clinician’s NPI and the payers they’re credentialed with.

  3. Use your clearinghouse’s claim scrubber to catch formatting errors before submission.

  4. Check whether each payer requires an electronic claim-filing enrollment before your first claim.

  5. Copy information directly from the insurance card rather than retyping it.

Build this checklist into your routine, apply these solutions for common claim submission errors, and you’ll spend less time reworking claims and more time doing the clinical work you love.

Sources

How SimplePractice streamlines running your practice

SimplePractice is HIPAA-compliant practice management software with everything you need to run your practice built into the platform—from booking and scheduling to insurance and client billing.

If you’ve been considering switching to an EHR system, SimplePractice empowers you to run a fully paperless practice—so you get more time for the things that matter most to you.
Try SimplePractice free for 30 days. No credit card required.

‌

simplepractice logo

Sign up for updates

By entering your email address, you are opting-in to receive emails from SimplePractice on its various products, solutions, and/or offerings. Unsubscribe anytime.

Apple StoreGoogle Play
hipaa logohitrust logopci compliant logo

Proudly made in Santa Monica, CA © 2026 SimplePractice, LLC